Are Coffee Bags Any Good? – West Berkshire Roastery Ir directamente al contenido
are coffee bags any good are coffee bags any good

Are Coffee Bags Any Good?

Are coffee bags any good? Yes, for what they are. A coffee bag is ground coffee in a tea-bag-style filter that you steep in a mug, and the cup it makes is a clear step up from instant. It is also weaker than a cafetière and dearer than brewing the same weight of ground coffee yourself. We roast and sell coffee bags, so read our verdict with that in mind.

By coffee bags we mean single-serve bags of ground coffee that you steep like a tea bag, not drip bags or the pouches that whole beans come in. Our guide to what coffee bags are covers the difference.

What do reviewers say about coffee bags?

Two independent tests stand out. Coffee Review, the US tasting site, tried 32 brew bags in April 2023. It found them better than instant coffee but about two to three points short of whole bean coffee on its 100-point scale, with muted aromas. Expert Reviews, a UK testing site, reached a similar verdict in October 2023. Its bags gave a body close to a cafetière's, but the cup was weaker and cost more than one made from ground coffee.

That puts coffee bags somewhere between instant and a cafetière.

Why do reviews of coffee bags disagree?

Reviews of the same format run from warm to scathing. Most of the gap comes from how much coffee is in the bag and how it gets brewed.

Dose

A 2024 Olive Magazine roundup found bags holding anywhere from 7.5g to 15g of coffee. A 7.5g bag in a full mug makes thin coffee, whatever the beans. Ours hold 10g, which in about 230ml of water is roughly 43g per litre. The Specialty Coffee Association's Golden Cup benchmark is 55g per litre, so that is a fifth short. Our post on how strong coffee bags are does the sums.

Steep time

Pack instructions often say two or three minutes. Expert Reviews found that too short and steeped its bags for about seven minutes in 240ml of water. Coffee Review recommended five to eight. Our own guide asks for three to five minutes and suggests starting at four, then adjusting to taste.

Heat loss

A mug cools faster than a pot, so a bag has less heat to work with. Coffee Review reported significant heat loss with lighter roasts and noted that a travel-mug lid keeps the heat in but blocks the aroma. Our method waits a minute after the kettle boils and then pours straight away.

Squeezing

A common warning is that squeezing a bag hard makes the cup bitter or muddy. Our method presses the bag against the side of the mug with a spoon before it comes out. If a cup ever tastes bitter, lift the bag out a minute sooner, as our guide on how to use coffee bags suggests.

How much do coffee bags cost against a cafetière?

A bag is the dearer way to make a mug of coffee. What the extra money buys is speed and almost no washing up.

Brew Price Cost per cup
Coffee bag, pack of 10 £6.95 about 70p
Coffee bag, pack of 30 £20.55 about 69p
Coffee bag, box of 300 £119.95 about 40p
Cafetière, 10g of our ground decaf £16.95 for 500g about 34p
Cafetière, 12.65g at standard strength £16.95 for 500g about 43p


We use Simmer Down Decaf for the comparison because the bags and our 500g bag of cafetière grind hold the same coffee, a Swiss Water Process decaf from Cajamarca in Peru. Ten grams of it costs about 34p, so a bag costs more than the coffee inside at every pack size. You are paying for the portioning and the filter as well. Brew a cafetière at the standard 55g per litre and a 230ml cup uses 12.65g, which is around 43p. Against that, the box of 300 comes in just under and the ten-pack runs about 27p over. The sums assume you already own a cafetière.

Who are coffee bags good for?

Coffee bags earn their place wherever you have a kettle and no kit. A desk or a campsite is the obvious fit. Offices are the clearest case, because one box serves a whole team with no machine to clean, and our guide to coffee bags for the office works out how many to buy.

Decaf drinkers have a case too. Simmer Down Decaf is 99.9% caffeine-free, made with the Swiss Water Process, and it is the same coffee we sell as beans, so a decaf drinker can have it without owning a grinder. For a regular cup, Bags of Gold is our medium roast, labelled strength 3 out of 5, with chocolate and caramel notes. Its inner bag is compostable, and our post on compostable coffee bags explains what that means.

I would start with a ten-pack of coffee bags and change one thing at a time, water first and then steep time.

Who should skip coffee bags?

If you already own a grinder and a cafetière and enjoy using them, a bag will feel like a step down, and I would not try to talk you out of that. The same goes if you want a very strong cup, because a bag fixes the dose and the grind and leaves you only the water and the steep to change. And if you drink several mugs a day at home, ground coffee costs less per cup, so our coffee beans are the better buy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are coffee bags any good?

Yes, for what they are. A coffee bag gives you ground coffee brewed by immersion, so it tastes better than instant and needs only a mug and a kettle. It will not match a cafetière for strength or aroma. Bags suit desks, travel and quick mornings better than slow weekends.

Are coffee bags as good as a cafetière?

Not quite. A cafetière lets you choose the dose, grind and time, so you can make a stronger cup. A coffee bag fixes the dose and the grind. Our 10g bag in 230ml of water works out at about 43g per litre, below the 55g standard, so use less water or steep it longer for more.

Are coffee bags worth the money?

It depends what you value. Our coffee bags cost 40p to 70p each depending on the pack, while 10g of our ground Simmer Down Decaf costs about 34p. You pay for speed and for not needing any equipment. If you drink several mugs a day at home, ground coffee is the cheaper choice.

Who should not buy coffee bags?

If you already own a grinder and a cafetière and enjoy using them, a bag will feel like a step down. If you drink several mugs a day at home, ground coffee costs less. Bags earn their place when you have a kettle and no kit, such as at a desk or on a campsite.

Dejar un comentario

Por favor tenga en cuenta que los comentarios deben ser aprobados antes de ser publicados